Landlord of industrial premises secures quashing of experimental traffic regulation order
- Details
North Yorkshire Council was misled by an officer report and breached the public sector equality duty when it imposed restrictions on a road used by heavy goods vehicles and serving a care home. The High Court quashed the order associated with this.
Those conclusions have come in a case brought by Peter Stevens Estates against North Yorkshire heard by Mr Justice Sheldon.
Peter Stevens Estates challenged an Experimental Traffic Regulation Order under paragraph 35 of Schedule 9 to the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984.
The order was intended to impose timed weight restrictions on Hambleton Grove, in Knaresborough, prohibiting goods vehicles in excess of 7.5t between of 7:00-09:30am and 15:00-16:30pm Monday-Friday, with no exemption for access.
Peter Stevens objected that its site in Hambleton Grove receives deliveries from heavy goods vehicles between 7:30 am and 4:30 pm.
It said the order was unlawful because the council was materially misled by the report of the assistant director of highways and infrastructure, which wrongly reported the peak afternoon times for HGV movements in the traffic data.
This gave a misleading impression that these occurred outside of the proposed timing restrictions when, in fact, they occurred within the proposed them.
The firm also alleged North Yorkshire failed to carry out the required balancing exercise under section 122 of the 1984 Act, as it did not consider what ‘reasonable access’ would be to its premises.
Hambleton Grove also serves the Manor House Care Home and it was claimed North Yorkshire failed to comply with section 149 of the Equality Act 2010 as it did not properly consider or identify the order’s impact on those with the protected characteristic of ‘age’.
North Yorkshire accepted the office report was factually erroneous over HGV peak afternoon movements, but said the error was minor and not materially misleading when read in the report as a whole
Sheldon J said: “There is nothing in the evidence before the court to indicate that the error made [in] the officer report was corrected before the decision was made.”
He added: “Accordingly, even if (as I assume to have been the case) the decision-maker looked at the appendices, including Appendix B which set out the raw data, there is nothing to suggest that the decision-maker realised that an error had been made and that, in fact, the peak pm HGV traffic for Site 2 occurred during the proposed restricted period and not otherwise.”
Sheldon J said the error “would have engendered a false sense of comfort in the decision-maker that the proposed restriction would not impact so negatively on businesses working from the industrial estate, as the restriction would not apply at a time when they had the highest HGV usage each afternoon”.
Had the error not been made “I cannot say that the decision-maker would necessarily have made the same decision as was in fact made”, the judge said.
Sheldon J found there has been a failure by North Yorkshire to comply with the public sector equality duty as the officer report did not grapple sufficiently with the potentially adverse effect of the order on residents of Manor House Care Home.
He found the officer report’s conclusion there were no adverse impacts on any of the protected characteristics “was not a reasonable one to have been arrived at”.
Concerns had been expressed by the care home about collection of refuse and clinical waste, “and without investigating the matter further it was simply not possible for the report writer to conclude that collections could be made outside of the restricted times or in lighter vehicles”.
He said the ground about the balancing exercise had become academic but would have been dismissed had it remained relevant.
Mark Smulian
Sponsored articles
Walker Morris supports Tower Hamlets Council in first known Remediation Contribution Order application issued by local authority
Property Solicitor
Lawyer
Generalist Lawyer
Locums



