Procurement challenges under the Procurement Act: why Verity is a warning on time limits
- Details
A High Court decision provides an important reminder of just how unforgiving the time limits for bringing a procurement challenge can be. Claire Gamage analyses the ruling and sets out some lessons for local authorities.
The case of Verity Healthcare Limited v Cambridgeshire County Council [2026] EWHC 2830 (TCC) is one of the latest decisions to consider the Procurement Act 2023 (PA23) and provides useful guidance on when a potential claimant will be treated as having knowledge of the circumstances giving rise to a claim. For suppliers, the message is simple: once a potential procurement breach comes into view, time is of the essence. For contracting authorities, meanwhile, the judgment demonstrates the value of transparency and good record-keeping throughout the procurement process, including before a tender is formally launched.
A challenge to a £928m framework
The dispute arose from Cambridgeshire County Council’s procurement of a framework for regulated homecare services for adults. With a proposed ten-year term and an estimated value of £928 million, it represented a significant opportunity for prospective providers.
As part of the first stage of the procurement, bidders were required to complete a Procurement Specific Questionnaire which acted as a compliance gateway. Among the requirements was that providers hold a current Care Quality Commission (CQC) rating of “Good” or above. Providers unable to meet that condition would be excluded.
Verity Healthcare Limited was a CQC-registered provider but did not hold the required rating. It challenged the condition as disproportionate and in breach of section 22 of PA23.
However, before the substantive merits of that argument could be determined, Verity faced a more fundamental problem: had it brought its claim in time?
When does the 30-day clock start ticking?
Under section 106(2) of PA23, proceedings must be commenced within 30 days, beginning with the day on which the supplier first knew, or ought to have known, about the circumstances giving rise to the claim.
The council's Tender Notice was published on Find a Tender on 15 July 2026. Verity issued its claim on 17 August and initially maintained that it had first become aware of the procurement and the CQC rating requirement on 19 July, but the evidence told a different story.
The council's audit log showed that Verity first accessed the e-procurement portal at 10.50pm on 18 July and registered an expression of interest one minute later. That one-day difference proved critical.
During the proceedings, Verity’s director provided a number of versions of events in an attempt to establish that, although he had accessed the portal on 18 July, he had not actually read the requirement for a “Good” CQC rating until the following day.
The court was unconvinced. It found that the claimant's evidence had sought to obfuscate the issue and offered inconsistent or incomplete versions of events. Even by the conclusion of proceedings, there was no clear account of what Verity’s director had actually read when accessing the portal.
Mrs Justice Jefford granted summary judgment to the council.
Actual versus constructive knowledge
Importantly, the council succeeded on two separate grounds.
First, the court found that Verity had actual knowledge of the procurement by 18 July at the latest. It followed that the claim issued on 17 August was one day outside the statutory period.
However, the judgment went further. Even if actual knowledge had not been established, the court found that Verity ought to have known about the procurement from 15 July, when the Tender Notice was published on Find a Tender.
That aspect of the ruling is particularly important for suppliers as Verity had not been monitoring Find a Tender directly, but instead, it relied on a separate tender notification service and monitored a previous e-procurement portal used by the council. The court did not consider that sufficient.
There was no obligation on the council to tell suppliers, including incumbent providers, which portal it intended to use. The judgment makes clear that suppliers are expected to take appropriate steps to monitor opportunities published through Find a Tender. Reliance on a service which may only notify suppliers days after the original notice has been published creates an obvious risk where such a short limitation period applies.
In other words, a supplier cannot necessarily postpone the start of the limitation period simply because it did not happen to see a procurement notice when it was published.
An informal challenge does not stop the clock
There is another practical lesson for would-be challengers.
Verity had written to the council on 21 July raising essentially the same issues that subsequently formed its claim. It nevertheless waited for the council's response before commencing proceedings.
The court found that there was no good reason to extend time. Verity had identified the relevant issues by 21 July, meaning a claim could have been prepared and issued within the limitation period. Nor did waiting for the council's response provide an adequate explanation. That response arrived on 11 August, at which point Verity could still have issued its claim in time. Instead, proceedings were commenced six days later.
For suppliers, this illustrates the danger of allowing correspondence with a contracting authority to dictate the timetable for litigation. Engaging constructively may be sensible, but the statutory limitation clock continues to run in parallel.
If a supplier believes there may be grounds for challenge, it should therefore take legal advice at the earliest opportunity rather than assume that pre-action correspondence will protect its position.
Lessons for local authorities
The judgment is not only important for challengers. There are useful lessons for contracting authorities, particularly around transparency before procurement formally begins.
Cambridgeshire County Council had undertaken extensive pre-market engagement. This included online information workshops, Preliminary Engagement Notices on Find a Tender and in-person sessions with providers, as well as a Planned Procurement Notice and Pipeline Notice.
Crucially, the requirement for a “Good” CQC rating had been referenced before the formal Tender Notice was published, which supported the council's position. The court considered that a reasonably well-informed and normally diligent tenderer would have been alive to the requirement. A provider which knew about the pre-market engagement, particularly one for whom the CQC condition could prevent participation altogether, would have known that it was an issue to look out for when the tender documents appeared.
For local authorities, the wider lesson is that early transparency can have benefits beyond supplier engagement. Clearly communicating significant eligibility requirements and retaining records of when and how they were communicated, may become important evidence if a procurement is subsequently challenged.
Speed matters
Verity also sought interim relief which would, in effect, have prevented its exclusion or suspended the procurement. Once summary judgment had been granted, that application could not succeed: the court would not grant interim relief in support of a claim which was doomed to failure. The court also concluded that, even absent summary judgment, damages would have provided Verity with an adequate remedy.
Ultimately, however, the most significant aspect of Verity is the starkness of the limitation point. A claim potentially involving a procurement worth hundreds of millions of pounds fell at the first hurdle because proceedings were brought too late.
For suppliers, the practical response should be to monitor Find a Tender closely, investigate potential breaches immediately and obtain legal advice as soon as a concern arises. Correspondence with an authority should not be allowed to distract from the litigation timetable.
For contracting authorities, meanwhile, the case underlines the value of transparent pre-market engagement and a clear audit trail.
Under PA23's 30-day limitation regime, when a procurement challenge emerges, what the parties knew, what they ought to have known and precisely when they knew it can make all the difference.
Claire Gamage is a Legal Director at national law firm TLT specialising in public procurement and public sector contracts.
Sponsored articles
Walker Morris supports Tower Hamlets Council in first known Remediation Contribution Order application issued by local authority
Property Solicitor
Lawyer
Generalist Lawyer
Locums
24-11-2026 12:00 pm
01-12-2026
01-12-2026 12:00 pm
To Be Confirmed
To Be Confirmed
To Be Confirmed
To Be Confirmed



