Local businesses threaten judicial review challenge over extension of time limit to fanzone next to Premier League stadium

The businesses objected that Stack - a collection of 56 bars and street food stalls housed in shipping containers and open until midnight near the football ground - diverted trade away from them.

A Newcastle City Council spokesperson said: “We had agreed to meet a number of businesses who had raised concerns around pressures on the hospitality industry, we recognise the concerns and want to work together.

“Prior to that meeting taking place we became aware that some of those businesses were planning to submit a judicial review to challenge the decision to extend the time limit for the Stack. As a result of these legal proceedings, which we would not be able to address in any meeting, it was postponed.

“While we understand and recognise the concerns raised, as a council, we cannot regulate competition in the city centre and that would not be grounds to refuse a planning application.”

Planning permission was initially granted to Stack in October 2023 and this has now been extended to 2031.

The spokesperson added: “This is an ongoing legal process and so we cannot comment further at this time but we do want to work with businesses to ensure Newcastle continues to thrive as a hub for hospitality.”

Stack chief executive Neill Winch said the decision to extend planning permission had been not only “hugely welcome”, but also “a testament to the venue’s role in enhancing the matchday and event experience at St. James’ Park”.

The NE1 Hospitality Group, which seeks the judicial review, told Chronicle Live : “This isn’t about growth - it’s about displacement. The Fanzone is drawing trade away from the very venues that helped build Newcastle’s reputation for hospitality. We’re not against progress but it must be fair and sustainable.”

Mark Smulian