LGR review was effort to “strengthen legal position” rather than honour original objectives, County Councils Network claims
- Details
Trust in the Government’s handling of Local Government Reorganisation (LGR) “is on the verge of completely evaporating”, the chair of the County Councils Network has claimed after criticising Whitehall’s approach to pausing and reviewing its decisions.
Speaking at the CCN's annual conference on Monday morning, Cllr Matthews said the Government's decision to withdraw and reconsider previous decisions was welcomed, but criticised the Government's new approach as providing "little reassurance that the process will be robust, fair and transparent".
His comments come after the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (MHCLG) announced last month that five areas would proceed towards LGR, following the pause in September. LGR decisions in nine other areas are to be scrapped to allow fresh decisions to be made.
MHCLG had halted the programme amid a series of legal challenges brought by councils.
Cllr Matthews told delegates that the move was less about reaching better decisions in line with the original objectives of reorganisation, "and more about strengthening the Government's legal position, ending previous challenges, and avoiding the full disclosure of previous ministerial advice".
He continued: "Whether or not that is the Government's intention, the perception is very real, and potentially, very damaging.
“Trust in the government’s handling of reorganisation has already been severely damaged. And for many, it is on the verge of completely evaporating."
The CCN chair said that the Government must be transparent and take the new decisions based on evidence rather than political or legal expediency.
The Secretary of State for Local Government, Angela Rayner, said last week the pause “was the right thing to do”.
She said: “I acknowledged the pain and frustration that was on people, but if I'm going to make a decision, I should read it and ensure I've given the respect to the councillors, to the local areas and to myself to ensure that I understood the issues and why people were in court over it and what the issues were.”
Elsewhere in his address, Cllr Matthews called on the Government to eradicate remaining SEND deficits and implement reform plans as promised, alongside fairer funding for county and rural unitary councils.
He also said councils must be resourced to move towards preventative children’s social care services.
Concluding, he said: "The need for our network has never been greater. This organisation is not defined by council structure, nor its name.
"It is defined by place. It is defined by the communities we represent and the unique challenges that bind us together. Those issues will not disappear because council structures change.
"Because in a new local government landscape, our network and its members must not become weaker. They must become stronger. More influential. More visible. And more ambitious.
"There will always be a need for a champion for county England. A trusted collective voice that government listens to. And one that will also strongly challenge ministers – whatever political persuasion they may be."
Adam Carey
Generalist Lawyer
Corporate Director of Legal and Regulatory Services
Civil Litigation Lawyer
Locums

